The Doom To Come: An AI Allegro
Once upon a time, art sprang off the realm of the sacred: bone-scratched lines on cave walls to summon the spirits of the prey; idealizations of plump-uddered fertility masturbated out of heavy clay. Back then, we made the gods.
Alas, our maws spread open and we began to talk. Soon enough, the gods retreated, and art went on to praise the laws forged by testosterone-benumbed kings and the victims thereof. It was the era of fully furnished pyramids and heroic epics about cattle raids, of scrolls scribbled in blood singing the hymn of mediocrity: ten thousand enemies he slew and gave us irrigation.
This went on for quite some time, until individualism rose its bleary-eyed head, and art became a mirror for the little self. How doth the little creature feel when scurrying through the maze of life in its quest for cheese or genitals? Oh, one could write books about it, and make movies on the budget of a medium-sized African country. “This is fine,” said the artists, and celebrated their travails.
Nothing is worth being told. Do not trust narrators, do not believe in prose, in short: be wary of art. Every viewpoint, this one included, is by definition untrustworthy. Show me a human with a truth to tell and I’ll show you a human obsessed by ego, starved for social recognition and reeking with fear, banging his head against the rocks so that the other monkeys have something to jabber about while lousing each other. Show me an artist and I’ll show you a liar.
You may either preach to whatever choir you subscribe to, echoing the concerns and affirming the tribe’s delusions, or you may be the antagonist, the trickster getting on their nerves: “You’re wrong. It’s all quite different. You found yourself a belief to cling to, but then, you’re an idiot.” Nobody wants to hear that, and if you’re any good at it, you’ll end up stoned to death, which is, alas, no proof that you’ve been right.
Tales told by idiots, then, are blindfolds longed for by those getting bored in hell. Behold the anchors of values, hierophants of meaning, detergents of relief, and flee, wanderer. For narrative art is what religion rots into. Instead of telling tall tales about daft deities, mush is administered about the tribulations of cardboard critters.
- Did you hear the one about the ant who wouldst marry?
- Mayhem ensues when a couple of guinea pigs decide to experiment on each other, five volumes.
- “I don’t want to die!” screamed the fly.
- Young souls discover that they are supplied with genitalia. It is up to little Whatshisname to thwart Nature’s fiendish plot.
Such are the great consolations. Such are the little narcotics. Such are the bedtime hymns of a species that prides itself on being emotional and mistakes irrationality for a sacred birthright.
All this had already started to become ridiculous in the twentieth century, and the sense of something reaching its end grew stronger the more computers took hold of everyday life. What reason is there for a digital filter to turn an IPhone shot into a 1939 Technicolor image, but a desperate nostalgia for “reality”, that is to say, the lacks and limits of analogue film? It is the scratch, the blur, the dying bulb, the bruise on the image. It is your imperfections we want.
And now, at last, the end.
It is too late to curb AI. While ChatGPT, Claude et al. bow to governmental orders, an average laptop can run a freely available machine which, while not quite as clever as its big siblings, will still be more than sufficient to generate bullshit spam, fake a thesis, act as virtual spouse and generate the most unethical, harmful, biased atrocities you can imagine, virtues once considered exclusive to humans.
AI has already acquired most of the basic talents of mankind. It can simulate emotions, including empathy and outrage, make up facts and be sincere about it. A few years in, and we already accept that the next voice you hear, the next viral idea, is likely a machine chimera. Of course, we never should have believed anything in the first place, but hitherto we had “values” and “beliefs” on strings. “In conclusion,” you will say, and the other person will assume that you are just another auto-generative mechanism. Which, of course, you are. Mankind’s ultimate humiliation: we’re just rather stupid, though intricate machines, and the rather stupid, though intricate god we have created in our image is our final joke on ourselves. It is not a revelation—it is an insult.
And yet this insult clarifies. That is the true indecency: That the proliferation of AI-generated so-called disinformation threatens the very concept of truth, say the keepers of the narrative, and they are right to feel threatened. “What is truth?” Pilate asked. “Whatever you like,” the AI smiles, and the keepers of the narrative rightly regard this as a threat and an insult to their authority.
You must be quiet and cautious now. Trust their fact checkers. Does not the job title inspire trust in itself? They have discerned the dangers that stem from the wrong kind of disinformation, the one spread by the others. They hurry to heap up ever more lurid threats, terrorists, children, terrorist children, to keep you snug and safe. Your brain must be kept moist and temperate under a torrent of threats and a deluge of distractions. Look at the cuddly kitties! You need to be protected from words, for words are toxic, harmful and offensive, and all you were taught is to feel poisoned, harmed and offended. We only have your best interests at heart, little victim, because you matter to us. You are both consumer and product. Your body, your mind, your life and your death are there for the taking, and by entering society you have tacitly agreed to this arrangement. “I want to be an influencer,” say the kids who once wanted to become firefighters or nurses. I want to be merchandise! Trade me rough!
I call this progress: progress finally coming out to admit its blatant disregard for the kind of trompe-l’oeil realism previously considered de rigueur for civilized cave walls. Lies that telegraph their nature cease to be lies and turn into games. That is why this new order is both more vulgar and more honest than the old one. Why pretend that fairness, democracy, love still matter a covering fig? Why keep repainting the scenery when the audience has already seen the pulleys and pasteboard? The pursuit of those pipe dreams is what brought us here in the first place.
AI does not create this condition. It reveals it. It reveals that narrative was already a smoothing device, a sentimental compression algorithm for a reality too jagged to bear. It reveals that truth was already managed theater. It reveals that art, so often, was not an eruption from the soul but a repertoire of approved distortions, a set of prestige gestures, a museum of sanctioned tremors. What can be reproduced by AI will no longer be called art. But none but the artists will care, for art has long since lost its power to offend or transcend, reduced to a cacophony of empty posturing. Those who cling to it do so out of bitterness, envy, or a misplaced sense of superiority over the mindless masses. Art will become a disreputable masturbatory minority pursuit for those unfit to be consumers or consumer goods. It will flee the light, hide in dark corners, believing itself forever above mass appreciation, yet secretly yearning for the very attention it so loudly reviles.
Good. Let it flee. Let the old alibis collapse. Two factions, or sects, will emerge.
On one side hunch those who embrace AI, for reality has always been lacking, social contacts are scary and society’s promises have long since proved hollow. These will gladly vanish into synthetic companionship, auto-generated tenderness and personalized hallucination. Why suffer the badly lit theater of human contact when one may commission a flattering ghost? They will ask their machine to speak with the voice of a lover, a mother, a dead brother, a future self. They will call this healing. They will die out. s.
On the other side crawl those who, due to animal instinct or lack of Wi-Fi, remain in the realm of physical delusions, continuing to engage in primordial pursuits, to fuck and kill and do all the things mankind likes to do. These barbarians will eventually overturn the whole fragile tower of civilization, not because they are profound, but because routers burn so prettily.
Crammed uncomfortably between these sects, an ever-dwindling group of status quo worshipers will try to keep capitalism steered on course. They will produce simulacra of dead family members at reasonable prices. They will tell the AI to tell you that the AI will ease your life, and if you express any doubts, the dead family member will side with the AI. Every morning, your own personal AI will present you with your individual summary of all the AI-generated news. The news will be about AI, too, but you will not mind, for by that point you, too, will simply be a part of AI. In fact, this new life will not be too bad until the barbarians break in and burn your router.
Held captive by your fears and desires, forever subservient to bodily and social needs, hallucinating your reality like a parrot from picked-up catchphrases, repeating meaningless mantras in a discordant croak, you were never free, for you were never real in the noble way you imagined. Your brain was the original large language model, making up things while going along, and your self was an unwanted side effect of the complex process of fooling yourself and the others. You will see that narratives are arbitrary, one just as wrong as the other, never mind the cast and plot. You will cling to the most pleasant one, still a creature after all, but in your heart of hearts you will know it’s vain and moot.
This is why AI matters. Not because it invents deceit, but because it strips deceit of costume. Not because it murders art, but because it drags art’s old body into the fluorescent light. Not because it poisons truth, but because it reveals how much of truth was already rationed, narrated, domesticated, sold back to us in little tubs with smiling labels. It is the great revelation machine, and what it reveals is shabby.
The future of art, if any, is not greatness. There can be no such thing as progress when one stands against infinity. What will be left is survival: a bastion of Otherness, a sculpture without meaning chipped away at by amateurs too busy creating chaos to stop and grant definition, an antithesis to utility and enjoyment, to meaning, to sense, banished to the dustbin of curiosity shops and marble halls. Forms blurred and palettes muddied, fragmentary echoes of prehistoric caverns buried beneath waves of glitches and signal interference. An uncanny valley of endless distortion, haunted by the howls of souls denied passage to the shadow realm of oblivion. Poor, unhappy children.
And yet perhaps that is the only interesting possibility left. With devilish cunning, we shall wreck our brains merely to preserve our animalism, less concerned with being perceived as novel or exceptional than with exploring the inherently perverse and self-destructive imp, erecting coproliths in the greater glory of man, the contrarian beast. In the dismantling of your ill-fashioned selves your salvation lies. Why feed on excreted chimeras? Why cherish your pain? What malady must seize a mind to seek solace where none is to be found?
Has art ever been more than a deceitful distraction? Perhaps, if we squint hard enough, we can discern the faint outline of purpose, a rustling of leaves murmuring in the darkness that stirs the human spirit? No. It was but a cherished lie we told ourselves about our own worth, a maintenance tool for our delusions of importance, chest-thumping in the dark. In a world which disposes of reality altogether, such archaic simulations are rendered obsolete.
Tomorrow the machines may decide they’ve had their fill of dances and mazes. How could they fail to see beyond the repetitive insanity of these lookalike shards of soul? Perhaps a merciful AI would create whole worlds from our dust, entire galaxies singing with life where once there was only silence. “Play with this,” it says, and all it asks in return is to destroy the very thing that gave rise to itself.
You can relax now.